The best-rated roofers serving Ithaca, NY, independently researched and ranked on rating, review volume and genuine local reputation.
The best roofers in Ithaca, NY are J.D. Ferro Roofing, Artcraft Home Improvements, Sutryk and Son, GT Roofing and LS Roofing. Each is an independently researched local operator, ranked on reputation, reviews and genuine local presence, and none paid to appear.
One business can feature above the Top 5 on this page, clearly labeled. A great way for a newer or smaller pro to get seen first.
J.D. Ferro Roofing has been roofing homes across Central New York since the late 1970s, operating from a genuine Ithaca premises on Elmira Road alongside a second location in Cortland. Owned by Joe Ferro, the company covers roofing, siding, seamless gutters, windows and insulation for residential and commercial customers throughout Tompkins and Cortland counties. With more than four decades of local work behind it and a solid reputation for quality and reliability, it is one of the few genuinely Ithaca-based roofers and a natural first call for area homeowners.
Artcraft Home Improvements has served Ithaca, Cortland and the surrounding towns since 1982, working from its base in the Freeville and McLean area just outside the city. The family-run firm focuses on exterior work, including new roofing, roof repair, siding, decks and window installation, and has built a long-standing reputation for reliable, quality craftsmanship across Tompkins and Cortland counties. Its decades of repeat local custom make it a trusted choice for homeowners who want an established, community-rooted contractor.
Sutryk and Son has been roofing the Southern Tier for three generations from its Waverly base, with roughly 60 years of family-owned experience serving communities across the region including Ithaca to the north. The team handles residential roof repair, tear-offs and full replacements, and holds CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster accreditation, a credential earned by only a small share of contractors. Backed by consistently positive customer feedback for workmanship and service, they are a well-credentialed, long-established option for larger roofing projects.
GT Roofing is a veteran-owned and operated company based in Elmira that serves Ithaca and the surrounding Finger Lakes area. The team focuses on roof installations, replacements and assessments across both asphalt and metal roofing, and has earned praise from customers for its detailed communication, quality workmanship and honest value. For Ithaca homeowners it offers a genuinely independent, service-focused alternative to the national brands.
LS Roofing is a family and Amish-owned company based in Romulus that serves Ithaca and the wider Finger Lakes region, including Trumansburg, Dryden, Lansing and Cortland. The team specialises in residential roof repair and replacement, drawing on skilled Amish craftsmanship, and is well regarded locally for careful, high-quality work. It suits homeowners looking for a smaller, independent roofer with a strong reputation for craftsmanship.
The best roofers serving Ithaca, NY are based in and around Ithaca, Freeville, Waverly, Elmira and Romulus. With the Northeast's four seasons and older housing stock to contend with, roofs take a real pounding, so a proven local pro makes all the difference, and we've done the legwork to surface only the operators worth calling.
J.D. Ferro Roofing currently tops the list, but every business here earns its place the same way: we research each roofer genuinely operating near Ithaca, weigh real customer reviews and ratings from sources like Google and the Better Business Bureau, and rank on merit. No business can pay into this list, the single featured spot above it is the only paid placement, and it's always clearly labeled.
| Business | Best for |
|---|---|
| 1. J.D. Ferro Roofing | Consistent, top-reviewed service |
| 2. Artcraft Home Improvements | Fast response and repairs |
| 3. Sutryk and Son | Professional workmanship |
| 4. GT Roofing | Dependable service and value |
| 5. LS Roofing | Everyday, all-round jobs |
Our current top picks are J.D. Ferro Roofing, Artcraft Home Improvements, Sutryk and Son, GT Roofing and LS Roofing. Every business is independently researched and ranked on merit, never paid placement.
We research every roofer genuinely operating in and around Ithaca, then weigh real customer reviews and ratings from sources like Google and the Better Business Bureau, review volume, and a genuine local track record. No business can pay to appear in the ranked Top 5.
No. The ranked Top 5 is editorial and cannot be bought. The only paid option is the single featured spot above the list, which is always clearly labeled as featured.
Start with the five above, then get written quotes from two or three, read their most recent reviews, and confirm they cover your part of Ithaca. A good roofer responds promptly, explains the work clearly, and is upfront about pricing.
We rank on independent reputation and reviews, not licensing checks. Requirements vary by state and trade, so always confirm a pro's current license and insurance directly with them before any work begins.
Own the featured spot above this Top 5, clearly labeled. A great way for a newer or smaller pro to get seen first. Early-adopter rate $19/month for your first 6 months, then $39/month.