The best-rated fencing serving Ithaca, NY, independently researched and ranked on rating, review volume and genuine local reputation.
The best fencing contractors in Ithaca, NY are Whitmore Fence Co., Ithaca Fences, Connor Fence Company, The Village Greenhouse and GreenScene Lawn and Garden. Each is an independently researched local operator, ranked on reputation, reviews and genuine local presence, and none paid to appear.
One business can feature above the Top 5 on this page, clearly labeled. A great way for a newer or smaller pro to get seen first.
Whitmore Fence is a long-established, family-run fence specialist based in Dryden, minutes from Ithaca, with several members of the Whitmore family running different parts of the business. They install and repair the full range of fencing, from chain link and vinyl to wood privacy, ornamental, post-and-rail and deer-exclusion fence, for both homes and commercial sites. As one of the area's dedicated fencing contractors rather than a general builder, they carry a strong local reputation for quality workmanship.
Ithaca Fences is a locally owned fence contractor run by Steven Davis, based in Dryden and serving Ithaca and the surrounding towns. With over a decade of experience, they install and repair residential and commercial fencing and are particularly well regarded for larger installations and steel or wrought-iron work. Customers describe their work as reliable and reasonably priced, making them a solid, accountable local option.
Connor Fence Company has installed fencing across the Finger Lakes region since 1987, working from Auburn a short drive north of Ithaca. As a dedicated fence specialist with its own showroom, they cover aluminum, vinyl, cedar, chain link, post-and-rail and custom gates, and complete every job with their own employees rather than subcontractors. Fully insured with more than three decades of experience, they suit homeowners who want a specialist firm and don't mind a company based just outside town.
The Village Greenhouse is a family-owned landscape and outdoor-construction company in Trumansburg, just west of Ithaca, with over 20 years serving the area. Alongside landscape design and stonework, they install aluminum and chain-link fencing, decks and other outdoor structures for homeowners across Ithaca and the surrounding communities. A good fit for clients who want fencing handled as part of a wider, well-established outdoor project.
GreenScene Lawn and Garden is a residential and commercial landscaping firm based in Freeville, near Ithaca, that designs and builds outdoor spaces from Ithaca through to Cortland. Their fencing work spans wood, composite, aluminum, vinyl and garden or deer fencing, alongside decks, patios and retaining walls. A capable local choice for homeowners wanting fencing built as part of a broader outdoor project by an established area company.
The best fencing contractors serving Ithaca, NY are based in and around Dryden, Auburn, Trumansburg and Freeville. With the Northeast's four seasons and older housing stock to contend with, fences get weathered hard, so a proven local pro makes all the difference, and we've done the legwork to surface only the operators worth calling.
Whitmore Fence Co. currently tops the list, but every business here earns its place the same way: we research each fencing contractor genuinely operating near Ithaca, weigh real customer reviews and ratings from sources like Google and the Better Business Bureau, and rank on merit. No business can pay into this list, the single featured spot above it is the only paid placement, and it's always clearly labeled.
| Business | Best for |
|---|---|
| 1. Whitmore Fence Co. | Consistent, top-reviewed service |
| 2. Ithaca Fences | Fast response and repairs |
| 3. Connor Fence Company | Professional workmanship |
| 4. The Village Greenhouse | Dependable service and value |
| 5. GreenScene Lawn and Garden | Everyday, all-round jobs |
Our current top picks are Whitmore Fence Co., Ithaca Fences, Connor Fence Company, The Village Greenhouse and GreenScene Lawn and Garden. Every business is independently researched and ranked on merit, never paid placement.
We research every fencing contractor genuinely operating in and around Ithaca, then weigh real customer reviews and ratings from sources like Google and the Better Business Bureau, review volume, and a genuine local track record. No business can pay to appear in the ranked Top 5.
No. The ranked Top 5 is editorial and cannot be bought. The only paid option is the single featured spot above the list, which is always clearly labeled as featured.
Start with the five above, then get written quotes from two or three, read their most recent reviews, and confirm they cover your part of Ithaca. A good fencing contractor responds promptly, explains the work clearly, and is upfront about pricing.
We rank on independent reputation and reviews, not licensing checks. Requirements vary by state and trade, so always confirm a pro's current license and insurance directly with them before any work begins.
Own the featured spot above this Top 5, clearly labeled. A great way for a newer or smaller pro to get seen first. Early-adopter rate $19/month for your first 6 months, then $39/month.